The Business Case Dictionary

Clear definitions and practical examples to help you understand business case terminology and apply it to your own business case.

What is Scenario Analysis? Pessimistic, Expected and Optimistic Scenarios

The pessimistic, expected and optimistic scenarios help decision-makers compare alternatives and understand potential outcomes.

What Is Scenario Analysis?

Scenario analysis helps decision-makers understand how an option could perform under different conditions. Pessimistic, expected and optimistic scenarios reveal the range of plausible outcomes and help test whether an option remains worthwhile.

How Is Scenario Analysis Different from Options Analysis?

Options analysis compares alternative courses of action to determine which best meets the organisation’s objectives. Scenario analysis tests how those options could perform under different conditions.

For example, options analysis might compare:

  • Continuing to operate the existing production equipment.
  • Upgrading the existing equipment.
  • Purchasing a new production system.


Scenario analysis would then test those options under pessimistic, expected and optimistic assumptions about demand, operating costs and productivity.

The distinction is between what we could do and what could happen under different conditions. Scenario analysis supports options analysis by showing whether the preferred option remains attractive across a range of plausible outcomes.

In this dictionary entry, the base case means the business-as-usual or do-minimum option. It is an option against which alternatives are compared, rather than a fourth performance scenario.

Pessimistic Scenario

The pessimistic scenario is a plausible downside scenario showing how an option could perform under less favourable conditions than those assumed in the expected scenario.

It uses cautious but credible assumptions, such as lower demand, higher costs, implementation delays or reduced benefits. These assumptions should form a combination that could reasonably occur together, rather than represent an absolute worst-case outcome.

Example: For the new production system, the pessimistic scenario assumes a longer implementation period, higher installation costs and smaller productivity gains.

Expected Scenario

The expected scenario, also called the central scenario, provides a central planning estimate based on the most reasonable, evidence-supported assumptions about costs, benefits, timing and delivery. It is not necessarily the mathematical midpoint between pessimistic and optimistic outcomes or a probability-weighted average.

Example: For the new production system, the expected scenario assumes achievable productivity improvements, realistic installation costs and a normal implementation period.

Optimistic Scenario

The optimistic scenario is a plausible upside scenario showing how an option could perform under more favourable conditions than those assumed in the expected scenario.

It uses favourable but credible assumptions, such as stronger productivity, lower costs or earlier benefits. These assumptions should form a combination that could reasonably occur together.

Example: For the new production system, the optimistic scenario assumes faster implementation and greater productivity gains, while allowing for the costs of supporting higher output.

Using Scenario Analysis to Compare Options

The base case option provides the benchmark against which alternatives are compared. Each option—including the base case where relevant—can be assessed under pessimistic, expected and optimistic scenarios. Use consistent assumptions about shared external conditions, such as market demand or inflation, while allowing for differences in how each option responds.

The term “base case” is sometimes also used to mean the expected scenario. To avoid confusion, this definition uses base case for the reference option and expected scenario for the central planning assumptions.

How Does Sensitivity Analysis Complement Scenario Analysis?

Sensitivity analysis tests how changes in individual assumptions affect an option’s results. In one-way sensitivity analysis, one assumption is varied at a time while the others remain at their expected-scenario values.

For example, when assessing a new production system, you could separately test:

  • Higher installation costs: What happens to net present value (NPV) if installation costs increase by 20%?

  • Lower productivity gains: Is the investment still worthwhile if productivity improves by only 10%, rather than the expected 15%?

  • Delayed benefits: How does a six-month delay in achieving the benefits affect the financial return?

These tests reveal which assumptions have the greatest influence on the outcome and where stronger evidence or closer management attention is needed. The ranges tested should reflect credible uncertainty, rather than applying the same percentage change to every assumption.

Sensitivity analysis can also identify a break-even or switching value: the point at which an option is no longer financially worthwhile or another option becomes preferable.


Scenario analysis tests a plausible combination of assumptions together; one-way sensitivity analysis isolates the effect of changing one assumption. Used together, they help decision-makers understand both the range of possible outcomes and the assumptions that matter most.

Turn understanding into action

Need Help Applying This to Your Business Case?

Chase Consulting can help you compare options, test assumptions and strengthen your business case for executive, CFO or Board consideration.

Explore Business Case Support
[bot_catcher]